Electroconvulsive Therapy
ECT is a highly effective treatment involving electrical stimulation of the brain under general anaesthesia to induce a generalised seizure. It is primarily used for severe, treatment-resistant depression.
Key Facts
Most effective treatment for severe depression — response rates ~50-70% in treatment-resistant cases Indicated for severe depression with psychotic features, catatonia, life-threatening self-neglect, and treatment-resistant depression NICE TA59: ECT should only be used for severe depressive illness, catatonia, or prolonged/severe mania when other treatments have failed Bilateral electrode placement is more effective than unilateral; right unilateral has fewer cognitive side effects Typical course: 6-12 sessions, given 2-3 times per week Consent and capacity: Valid consent required; can be given under MHA Section 58 or Section 62 (emergency) Most common side effect: Short-term memory impairment (usually resolves within weeks-months) Absolute contraindications: Raised intracranial pressure (risk of herniation), phaeochromocytoma
Overview
Key Facts
ECT remains one of the most effective treatments in psychiatry, particularly for severe and life-threatening depression. Despite public controversy, it is a safe, evidence-based treatment when used appropriately.
Epidemiology
Approximately 2,500-4,000 patients receive ECT annually in England. Use has declined over recent decades but remains an important treatment option for severe illness.
Aetiology
Mechanism of action (not fully understood):
- Generalised seizure activates multiple neurotransmitter systems simultaneously
- Anticonvulsant theory: Repeated seizures raise seizure threshold → normalises neural circuit hyperexcitability
- Neuroplasticity: Increases BDNF, promotes hippocampal neurogenesis
- Neuroendocrine: Normalises HPA axis dysregulation
- Neurotransmitter: Increases serotonin, noradrenaline, dopamine sensitivity; enhances GABAergic transmission
Pathophysiology
- Electrical stimulus (typically 0.5-1.0 seconds of brief-pulse current at 800mA) induces a generalised tonic-clonic seizure lasting 15-60 seconds
- Seizure must be adequate duration (≥15 seconds motor, ≥25 seconds EEG) for therapeutic effect
- The seizure, not the electrical current, produces the therapeutic effect
Clinical Presentation
Indications (NICE TA59)
- Severe depressive illness — especially with psychotic features, suicidal ideation, refusal to eat/drink
- Catatonia — rapid, highly effective response
- Prolonged or severe mania — when other treatments have failed
- Treatment-resistant schizophrenia — augmentation of clozapine (limited evidence)
- Severe puerperal psychosis — particularly with catatonic features
- Life-threatening self-neglect — not eating or drinking due to depression/psychosis
Pre-ECT Assessment
- Full medical history and physical examination
- Anaesthetic assessment
- Baseline cognitive assessment (e.g., MoCA)
- Informed consent (or MHA provisions)
- Bloods: FBC, U&Es, ECG
- Consider CXR and CT head in older adults or if clinically indicated
Red Flags/Contraindications
- Absolute: Raised intracranial pressure, phaeochromocytoma
- Relative: Recent MI (<3 months), unstable angina, recent stroke, intracranial aneurysm, aortic/cerebral aneurysm, retinal detachment
- High-risk anaesthesia patients need careful assessment
Differential Diagnosis
| Clinical Scenario | Alternative Treatment | When to Consider ECT |
|---|---|---|
| Severe depression with psychotic features | Antidepressant + antipsychotic | Failed pharmacotherapy or life-threatening |
| Catatonia | Lorazepam trial | Lorazepam-refractory or severe |
| Treatment-resistant depression | Augmentation strategies | Failed ≥2 adequate antidepressant trials |
| Severe mania | Mood stabiliser + antipsychotic | Failed pharmacotherapy |
| Puerperal psychosis | Antipsychotic + mood stabiliser | Severe or catatonic features |
Diagnosis / Investigation
Pre-ECT
- FBC, U&Es: Baseline bloods
- ECG: Cardiac assessment
- CXR: If clinically indicated
- Cognitive assessment: MoCA or MMSE — baseline for comparison
- Anaesthetic review: ASA grading
During Treatment
- EEG monitoring: Seizure duration and quality
- Motor seizure monitoring: Cuff technique (isolate limb from muscle relaxant to observe motor seizure)
- Vital signs: Continuous during and post-procedure
Post-Treatment
- Cognitive assessment: Repeat MoCA/MMSE at intervals
- Clinical rating scales: PHQ-9, HAM-D — monitor response
Management
ECT Procedure
- General anaesthesia: Short-acting (propofol or thiopental)
- Muscle relaxant: Suxamethonium (to prevent injury from convulsion)
- Atropine/glycopyrrolate: May be used to reduce secretions and prevent bradycardia
- Electrode placement: Bilateral (more effective) or right unilateral (fewer cognitive effects)
- Stimulus: Brief-pulse (0.5-1.5ms) or ultra-brief pulse (0.3ms — less cognitive effects, may need higher charge)
Treatment Course
- Typically 6-12 sessions (twice weekly in UK)
- Assess response after each session and formally after 6 sessions
- Stop if no response after adequate trial
- Continuation/maintenance ECT: Consider for relapse prevention (weekly → fortnightly → monthly)
Post-ECT
- Continuation pharmacotherapy: Antidepressant (+ lithium augmentation) to prevent relapse
- Without maintenance treatment, relapse rate is ~50% within 6 months after ECT
Legal Framework
- Consent: Valid informed consent required
- MHA Section 58: If detained and lacks capacity or refuses — SOAD (Second Opinion Appointed Doctor) can authorise
- MHA Section 62: Emergency ECT without SOAD — life-threatening situations only
- MCA: If patient lacks capacity and is not detained, consider Court of Protection
Referral Criteria
- Specialist psychiatrist decision — discuss with patient and carers
- Anaesthetic assessment
- Consent/capacity assessment
Prognosis
- Response rates: 50-70% in treatment-resistant depression; higher (~80-90%) in severe depression with psychotic features
- Catatonia: >80% response rate — often dramatic improvement after first session
- Relapse: ~50% within 6 months without continuation treatment; continuation pharmacotherapy or maintenance ECT reduces this
- Cognitive effects: Short-term retrograde and anterograde amnesia is common; usually resolves within weeks to months; bilateral > unilateral; some patients report persistent memory difficulties
- Mortality: <1 in 50,000 treatments — similar to general anaesthesia risk for minor procedures
Other Relevant Information
ECT Quick Reference
| Parameter | Detail |
|---|---|
| Anaesthetic | Propofol or thiopental |
| Muscle relaxant | Suxamethonium |
| Electrode placement | Bilateral or right unilateral |
| Seizure duration required | ≥15 seconds motor, ≥25 seconds EEG |
| Course | 6-12 sessions, 2× weekly (UK) |
| Maintenance | Weekly → monthly if indicated |
| Main side effect | Short-term memory impairment |
| Absolute contraindication | Raised intracranial pressure |