TextbookGeriatric MedicineComprehensive Geriatric Assessment

Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment

Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment (CGA) is a multidimensional, interdisciplinary diagnostic process to determine the medical, psychological, functional, and social capabilities of a frail older person to develop a coordinated care plan.

Key Facts

CGA is the gold standard for assessment and management of frail older people in hospital and community settings Meta-analysis evidence (Ellis et al. 2011, 2017): CGA increases the likelihood of being alive and in own home at 12 months (NNT = 13) CGA reduces mortality (OR 0.76), institutionalisation, functional decline, and length of stay Multidomain assessment: medical, functional, cognitive, psychological, nutritional, social, environmental MDT approach: geriatrician, nurse, physiotherapist, occupational therapist, dietitian, speech therapist, social worker, pharmacist CGA should be delivered in a dedicated geriatric unit where possible (associated with best outcomes) Goal-setting is a key component: patient-centred goals guide the management plan CGA is process-driven (not just a one-off assessment) with regular review and adaptation

Overview

Key Facts

CGA is one of the most evidence-based interventions in medicine for improving outcomes in frail older adults. It is both an assessment tool and a management framework.

Epidemiology

  • Approximately 30-50% of hospital inpatients >65 would benefit from CGA
  • Acute frailty units using CGA have improved outcomes compared to standard care
  • CGA is recommended by NICE for all frail older people admitted to hospital

Aetiology

CGA addresses the multifactorial nature of illness and decline in older adults, recognising that a single disease model is inadequate.

Pathophysiology

  • Frail older adults have reduced physiological reserve
  • Acute illness causes disproportionate functional decline
  • Multiple interacting problems (medical, cognitive, psychological, social) require a holistic approach
  • CGA identifies these interactions and creates an integrated management plan

Clinical Presentation

Indications for CGA

  • Frail older adults (CFS ≥5)
  • Multiple comorbidities
  • Functional decline
  • Recurrent admissions
  • Complex discharge planning
  • Cognitive impairment with comorbidities
  • Falls and mobility problems
  • Polypharmacy

CGA Process

  1. Multidomain assessment by MDT
  2. Problem identification across all domains
  3. Goal-setting with patient and family
  4. Creation of integrated care plan
  5. Implementation
  6. Regular review and adaptation

Red Flags Triggering CGA

  • Functional decline not explained by acute illness alone
  • Delirium
  • Recurrent falls
  • New incontinence
  • Significant weight loss
  • Carer breakdown
  • Discharge to higher level of care being considered

Differential Diagnosis

DiagnosisKey FeaturesInvestigation
Single-organ diseaseTypical presentation, no complexityStandard investigation
Multimorbidity without frailtyMultiple conditions but good functionCGA not necessarily needed
Frailty syndromesFalls, delirium, immobility, incontinenceCGA indicated
End of lifeProgressive decline despite treatmentPalliative approach within CGA

Diagnosis / Investigation

Bedside

  • Medical: comprehensive medical history, medication reconciliation
  • Functional: ADLs (Barthel Index), IADLs (Lawton Scale), mobility (TUG, gait speed)
  • Cognitive: 4AT (delirium), AMT-10, MoCA/ACE-III (dementia)
  • Psychological: GDS-15 (depression), GAD-7 (anxiety)
  • Nutritional: MUST score, weight, BMI, dietary history
  • Social: living situation, carers, social support, advance care planning
  • Environmental: home safety assessment

Bloods

  • FBC, U&Es, LFTs, TFTs, calcium, vitamin D, B12, folate, ferritin
  • HbA1c, albumin, CRP
  • Medication levels where appropriate

Imaging

  • As directed by CGA findings

Special Tests

  • Medication review (STOPP/START)
  • Swallow assessment if dysphagia
  • Continence assessment
  • Tissue viability assessment
  • Carer strain assessment

Management

Non-pharmacological

  • Personalised care plan based on CGA findings and patient goals
  • Rehabilitation: physiotherapy (strength, balance), OT (functional goals, ADLs)
  • Cognitive stimulation: for dementia/delirium prevention
  • Nutritional optimisation: dietitian input, supplementation
  • Social prescribing: address isolation, community activities
  • Discharge planning: start from admission; MDT assessment of safe discharge
  • Follow-up: community geriatric teams, GP care plan

Pharmacological

  • Medication optimisation: STOPP/START criteria, deprescribing
  • Treat identified conditions: heart failure, infection, depression, pain
  • Preventive measures: vitamin D, vaccination, bone protection

Surgical/Interventional

  • CGA informs surgical risk assessment in older adults
  • Proactive geriatric liaison in surgical patients (hip fracture, emergency surgery)
  • Perioperative CGA reduces post-operative complications

Referral Criteria

  • All frail older adults admitted to hospital
  • Complex community patients with functional decline
  • Pre-operative assessment for frail surgical patients
  • Recurrent admissions
  • Complex discharge planning

Prognosis

  • CGA in hospital: NNT 13 to prevent one death or institutional placement at 12 months
  • CGA reduces mortality: OR 0.76 (95% CI 0.64-0.90)
  • CGA reduces institutionalisation: OR 0.80
  • Outcomes best when delivered by a dedicated geriatric MDT on a specialist unit
  • CGA in the community also improves outcomes (reduces hospital admissions)
  • Goal attainment is associated with improved patient satisfaction and quality of life

Other Relevant Information

CGA Domains and Assessment Tools

DomainKey Tools
MedicalProblem list, medication review (STOPP/START), comorbidity index (Charlson)
FunctionalBarthel Index, Lawton IADL Scale, TUG, gait speed
Cognitive4AT, AMT-10, MoCA, ACE-III
PsychologicalGDS-15 (depression), CAM (delirium)
NutritionalMUST, MNA
SocialSocial history, carer assessment
EnvironmentalHome hazard assessment, community resources

Evidence for CGA

StudyFinding
Ellis et al. (2011, 2017)CGA improves survival and likelihood of remaining at home
Stuck et al. (1993)CGA reduces functional decline
Baztan et al. (2009)Acute geriatric units reduce mortality and LOS
POPS studyProactive geriatric care in surgery improves outcomes