Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment
Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment (CGA) is a multidimensional, interdisciplinary diagnostic process to determine the medical, psychological, functional, and social capabilities of a frail older person to develop a coordinated care plan.
Key Facts
CGA is the gold standard for assessment and management of frail older people in hospital and community settings Meta-analysis evidence (Ellis et al. 2011, 2017): CGA increases the likelihood of being alive and in own home at 12 months (NNT = 13) CGA reduces mortality (OR 0.76), institutionalisation, functional decline, and length of stay Multidomain assessment: medical, functional, cognitive, psychological, nutritional, social, environmental MDT approach: geriatrician, nurse, physiotherapist, occupational therapist, dietitian, speech therapist, social worker, pharmacist CGA should be delivered in a dedicated geriatric unit where possible (associated with best outcomes) Goal-setting is a key component: patient-centred goals guide the management plan CGA is process-driven (not just a one-off assessment) with regular review and adaptation
Overview
Key Facts
CGA is one of the most evidence-based interventions in medicine for improving outcomes in frail older adults. It is both an assessment tool and a management framework.
Epidemiology
- Approximately 30-50% of hospital inpatients >65 would benefit from CGA
- Acute frailty units using CGA have improved outcomes compared to standard care
- CGA is recommended by NICE for all frail older people admitted to hospital
Aetiology
CGA addresses the multifactorial nature of illness and decline in older adults, recognising that a single disease model is inadequate.
Pathophysiology
- Frail older adults have reduced physiological reserve
- Acute illness causes disproportionate functional decline
- Multiple interacting problems (medical, cognitive, psychological, social) require a holistic approach
- CGA identifies these interactions and creates an integrated management plan
Clinical Presentation
Indications for CGA
- Frail older adults (CFS ≥5)
- Multiple comorbidities
- Functional decline
- Recurrent admissions
- Complex discharge planning
- Cognitive impairment with comorbidities
- Falls and mobility problems
- Polypharmacy
CGA Process
- Multidomain assessment by MDT
- Problem identification across all domains
- Goal-setting with patient and family
- Creation of integrated care plan
- Implementation
- Regular review and adaptation
Red Flags Triggering CGA
- Functional decline not explained by acute illness alone
- Delirium
- Recurrent falls
- New incontinence
- Significant weight loss
- Carer breakdown
- Discharge to higher level of care being considered
Differential Diagnosis
| Diagnosis | Key Features | Investigation |
|---|---|---|
| Single-organ disease | Typical presentation, no complexity | Standard investigation |
| Multimorbidity without frailty | Multiple conditions but good function | CGA not necessarily needed |
| Frailty syndromes | Falls, delirium, immobility, incontinence | CGA indicated |
| End of life | Progressive decline despite treatment | Palliative approach within CGA |
Diagnosis / Investigation
Bedside
- Medical: comprehensive medical history, medication reconciliation
- Functional: ADLs (Barthel Index), IADLs (Lawton Scale), mobility (TUG, gait speed)
- Cognitive: 4AT (delirium), AMT-10, MoCA/ACE-III (dementia)
- Psychological: GDS-15 (depression), GAD-7 (anxiety)
- Nutritional: MUST score, weight, BMI, dietary history
- Social: living situation, carers, social support, advance care planning
- Environmental: home safety assessment
Bloods
- FBC, U&Es, LFTs, TFTs, calcium, vitamin D, B12, folate, ferritin
- HbA1c, albumin, CRP
- Medication levels where appropriate
Imaging
- As directed by CGA findings
Special Tests
- Medication review (STOPP/START)
- Swallow assessment if dysphagia
- Continence assessment
- Tissue viability assessment
- Carer strain assessment
Management
Non-pharmacological
- Personalised care plan based on CGA findings and patient goals
- Rehabilitation: physiotherapy (strength, balance), OT (functional goals, ADLs)
- Cognitive stimulation: for dementia/delirium prevention
- Nutritional optimisation: dietitian input, supplementation
- Social prescribing: address isolation, community activities
- Discharge planning: start from admission; MDT assessment of safe discharge
- Follow-up: community geriatric teams, GP care plan
Pharmacological
- Medication optimisation: STOPP/START criteria, deprescribing
- Treat identified conditions: heart failure, infection, depression, pain
- Preventive measures: vitamin D, vaccination, bone protection
Surgical/Interventional
- CGA informs surgical risk assessment in older adults
- Proactive geriatric liaison in surgical patients (hip fracture, emergency surgery)
- Perioperative CGA reduces post-operative complications
Referral Criteria
- All frail older adults admitted to hospital
- Complex community patients with functional decline
- Pre-operative assessment for frail surgical patients
- Recurrent admissions
- Complex discharge planning
Prognosis
- CGA in hospital: NNT 13 to prevent one death or institutional placement at 12 months
- CGA reduces mortality: OR 0.76 (95% CI 0.64-0.90)
- CGA reduces institutionalisation: OR 0.80
- Outcomes best when delivered by a dedicated geriatric MDT on a specialist unit
- CGA in the community also improves outcomes (reduces hospital admissions)
- Goal attainment is associated with improved patient satisfaction and quality of life
Other Relevant Information
CGA Domains and Assessment Tools
| Domain | Key Tools |
|---|---|
| Medical | Problem list, medication review (STOPP/START), comorbidity index (Charlson) |
| Functional | Barthel Index, Lawton IADL Scale, TUG, gait speed |
| Cognitive | 4AT, AMT-10, MoCA, ACE-III |
| Psychological | GDS-15 (depression), CAM (delirium) |
| Nutritional | MUST, MNA |
| Social | Social history, carer assessment |
| Environmental | Home hazard assessment, community resources |
Evidence for CGA
| Study | Finding |
|---|---|
| Ellis et al. (2011, 2017) | CGA improves survival and likelihood of remaining at home |
| Stuck et al. (1993) | CGA reduces functional decline |
| Baztan et al. (2009) | Acute geriatric units reduce mortality and LOS |
| POPS study | Proactive geriatric care in surgery improves outcomes |