Chronic Pain Management
Chronic primary pain is pain persisting or recurring for more than 3 months without an identifiable underlying condition, affecting approximately 1 in 3 UK adults, managed with a biopsychosocial approach emphasising exercise, psychological therapies, and judicious pharmacological treatment according to NICE NG193.
Key Facts
Chronic pain (>3 months) affects approximately 28 million adults in the UK (43%); chronic primary pain affects 1 in 3 NICE NG193 distinguishes chronic primary pain (fibromyalgia, chronic widespread pain, CRPS, IBS, chronic headache) from chronic secondary pain (identifiable cause, e.g. OA, neuropathy) Do NOT offer paracetamol, NSAIDs, opioids, gabapentinoids, benzodiazepines, antidepressants (for pain), or local anaesthetics for chronic primary pain (NICE NG193 — controversial recommendation) Recommended treatments for chronic primary pain: supervised group exercise, CBT/ACT (acceptance and commitment therapy), and acupuncture (NICE NG193) Opioid prescribing crisis: approximately 5.6 million adults in England on opioids; evidence of benefit beyond 3 months is lacking; significant harm (dependence, OIH, falls) Amitriptyline 10-75mg ON, duloxetine 60mg OD, or gabapentin 300-1200mg TDS are evidence-based for chronic secondary pain (neuropathic pain, NICE CG173) Multidisciplinary pain management programmes are the gold standard for complex chronic pain Pain neuroscience education: helps patients understand that chronic pain reflects sensitised nervous system, not ongoing tissue damage
Overview
Key Facts
Chronic pain is a major public health issue and one of the most common reasons for GP consultation. NICE NG193 has significantly changed the approach to chronic primary pain, moving away from pharmacological management towards exercise, psychological therapy, and self-management.
Epidemiology
- Chronic pain: 28 million UK adults (~43%)
- Moderate-severe chronic pain: 14% of adults
- Higher prevalence in women, older adults, lower socioeconomic groups
- Associated with significant disability, mental health comorbidity, and social isolation
- Accounts for 4.6 million GP appointments/year in England
Aetiology
- Chronic primary pain: no identifiable underlying condition; includes fibromyalgia, chronic widespread pain, complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS), chronic pelvic pain, chronic headache, IBS
- Chronic secondary pain: identifiable underlying cause — neuropathic pain (diabetic neuropathy, post-herpetic neuralgia), musculoskeletal (OA, RA), cancer pain, post-surgical
Pathophysiology
- Central sensitisation: amplification of neural signalling within the CNS resulting in pain hypersensitivity
- Peripheral sensitisation: lowered threshold of nociceptors
- Neuroplasticity: structural and functional changes in pain-processing areas (somatosensory cortex, prefrontal cortex, limbic system)
- Descending modulation dysfunction: impaired inhibitory pain pathways
- Psychosocial amplification: fear-avoidance, catastrophising, depression, anxiety, social factors all modulate pain experience
- Chronic primary pain is not 'imagined' — it reflects real neurobiological changes in pain processing
Clinical Presentation
Chronic Primary Pain
- Widespread pain without identifiable tissue damage or pathology
- Often associated with: fatigue, sleep disturbance, cognitive difficulties ('fibro fog'), low mood
- Disproportionate to any identifiable pathology
- Affects function and quality of life significantly
Assessment
- Comprehensive biopsychosocial assessment
- Pain characteristics: location, duration, quality, severity (VAS/NRS), aggravating/relieving factors
- Impact on function: work, sleep, mood, relationships, activities
- Psychological: PHQ-9, GAD-7, catastrophising (PCS)
- Current medications and previous treatments tried
- Medication use: opioid dose, escalation pattern, aberrant behaviour
Red Flags (Exclude Serious Pathology)
- New onset pain in patient >50 years with weight loss (malignancy)
- Neurological deficit (cauda equina, cord compression)
- Bone pain with raised calcium (metastases)
- Night pain/morning stiffness >45 min (inflammatory arthritis)
- Fever with pain (infection)
Differential Diagnosis
| Diagnosis | Key Features | Investigation |
|---|---|---|
| Fibromyalgia | Widespread pain, fatigue, sleep disturbance, tender points | Clinical (ACR 2016 criteria) |
| Neuropathic pain | Burning, shooting, allodynia, in nerve distribution | DN4 questionnaire, nerve conduction |
| Osteoarthritis | Joint pain, stiffness, age-related | Clinical, X-ray |
| Inflammatory arthritis | Morning stiffness >45 min, joint swelling, raised ESR/CRP | ESR, CRP, RF, anti-CCP |
| Depression with somatic symptoms | Low mood predominant, diffuse aches | PHQ-9 |
| Medication-overuse headache | Daily headache, analgesic use >15 days/month | Headache diary |
Diagnosis / Investigation
Bedside
- Pain assessment scales (VAS 0-10, NRS)
- Functional assessment
- PHQ-9, GAD-7 (comorbid depression/anxiety)
- Brief Pain Inventory
- DN4 (Douleur Neuropathique 4): screening for neuropathic pain component
Bloods
- FBC, ESR, CRP (exclude inflammatory/infectious cause)
- TFTs (hypothyroidism can cause myalgia)
- Vitamin D (deficiency common in chronic pain patients)
- HbA1c (diabetic neuropathy)
- Calcium (bony metastases, hyperparathyroidism)
Imaging
- Not routinely indicated for chronic primary pain (may reinforce unhelpful beliefs)
- Targeted imaging for suspected chronic secondary pain (X-ray for OA, MRI for suspected structural pathology)
Special Tests
- Nerve conduction studies/EMG: if neuropathic pain suspected
- DEXA: if osteoporosis suspected
- DN4 questionnaire: ≥4/10 suggests neuropathic component
Management
Chronic Primary Pain (NICE NG193)
- Recommended:
- Supervised group exercise programme: most effective intervention
- Psychological therapy: CBT or ACT (acceptance and commitment therapy)
- Acupuncture: consider a single course
- Antidepressant for pain: ONLY if also treating comorbid depression/anxiety; NOT for pain alone
- Pain neuroscience education
- Self-management support
- NOT recommended (NICE NG193 — for chronic primary pain specifically):
- Paracetamol, NSAIDs, opioids, gabapentinoids, benzodiazepines, antidepressants (for pain), ketamine, local anaesthetics, corticosteroid injections, TENS
Chronic Secondary Pain — Neuropathic Component (NICE CG173)
- First-line: amitriptyline 10mg ON (titrate to 75mg), duloxetine 60mg OD, gabapentin 300mg TDS (titrate to 1200mg TDS), or pregabalin 75mg BD (titrate to 300mg BD)
- Second-line: switch or combine first-line agents
- Third-line: tramadol (short-term), specialist referral
- Topical: capsaicin 0.075% cream, lidocaine 5% patches (post-herpetic neuralgia)
Opioid Management
- Avoid long-term opioids for chronic non-cancer pain wherever possible
- If already on long-term opioids: discuss dose reduction, agree tapering plan
- Review all patients on opioids: risks (dependence, OIH, falls, endocrine effects), benefits (often diminishing)
- Use opioid risk tools (ORT) before initiating
Referral Criteria
- Multidisciplinary pain clinic: complex chronic pain, failed primary care management, opioid reduction support
- Psychology/IAPT: for CBT/ACT
- Physiotherapy: for supervised exercise
- Addiction services: if problematic opioid/gabapentinoid use
Prognosis
- Chronic primary pain is a long-term condition requiring ongoing self-management
- CBT/ACT: reduces pain-related disability and distress in 40-60%; does not necessarily reduce pain intensity
- Exercise: improves function and pain by 20-30% in most studies
- Opioids: no evidence of long-term benefit beyond 3 months for chronic non-cancer pain; significant risk of harm
- Prognosis is improved by: early intervention, active coping strategies, psychological support, sustained physical activity
- Poor prognostic factors: catastrophising, fear-avoidance, ongoing compensation/litigation, depression, social isolation
- Many patients achieve meaningful improvement in function and quality of life with multimodal management
Other Relevant Information
NICE NG193 vs CG173 — Key Differences
| Feature | Chronic Primary Pain (NG193) | Neuropathic Pain (CG173) |
|---|---|---|
| Paracetamol | NOT recommended | May be used |
| NSAIDs | NOT recommended | May be used (short-term) |
| Opioids | NOT recommended | Tramadol (short-term) |
| Gabapentinoids | NOT recommended | First-line |
| Amitriptyline | NOT for pain | First-line |
| CBT/ACT | Recommended | Recommended |
| Exercise | Recommended | Recommended |
Fibromyalgia — ACR 2016 Revised Diagnostic Criteria
| Criterion | Detail |
|---|---|
| Widespread pain index (WPI) ≥7 AND symptom severity scale (SSS) ≥5 | OR |
| WPI 4-6 AND SSS ≥9 | |
| Symptoms present ≥3 months | |
| No other disorder explaining pain |
Opioid Concerns in Chronic Pain
| Issue | Detail |
|---|---|
| Tolerance | Dose escalation for same effect |
| Opioid-induced hyperalgesia | Opioids paradoxically increase pain sensitivity |
| Dependence | Physical and psychological |
| Endocrine effects | Hypogonadism, adrenal insufficiency |
| Immune suppression | Reduced immune function |
| Falls/fractures | Especially in elderly |