Fracture Management Principles
Fracture management follows principles of recognition, reduction, immobilisation, and rehabilitation. Open fractures require urgent antibiotics, and neurovascular assessment is mandatory before and after any manipulation.
Key Facts
Fracture description: Bone, site (proximal/shaft/distal), pattern (transverse/oblique/spiral/comminuted), displacement, angulation, open vs closed Open fractures: Classified by Gustilo-Anderson (I-IIIC); require IV antibiotics within 1 hour (co-amoxiclav 1.2g ± gentamicin), tetanus prophylaxis, and urgent orthopaedic/plastic surgery involvement — BOAST 4 guidelines Neurovascular assessment before and after any fracture manipulation — document sensation, motor function, pulses, capillary refill Ottawa Ankle Rules and Ottawa Knee Rules: Validated clinical decision rules to determine need for X-ray — high sensitivity for fractures Salter-Harris classification (I-V): For paediatric physeal (growth plate) injuries — Type II most common; Type V worst prognosis Compartment syndrome: Severe pain (out of proportion to injury), pain on passive stretch, tense compartment — surgical emergency requiring fasciotomy within 6 hours Fat embolism syndrome: Presents 24-72h after long bone fracture with petechial rash, hypoxia, and confusion All fractures should have adequate analgesia: Femoral nerve block for femoral shaft; Bier's block for forearm manipulation
Overview
Key Facts
Fracture management is a core skill in emergency medicine. The principles of assessment, reduction, immobilisation, and rehabilitation apply across all fracture types, with specific considerations for open fractures, paediatric injuries, and potential complications.
Epidemiology
Fractures account for approximately 5-8% of all ED attendances. Distal radius fracture is the most common fracture in adults overall. Hip fractures are the most common in the elderly (~80,000/year in UK). Paediatric fractures account for approximately 25% of all fractures — forearm fractures are most common.
Aetiology
- Traumatic: Falls, RTCs, sports injuries, assaults
- Pathological: Through abnormal bone — osteoporosis (most common), metastases, primary bone tumours, Paget's disease, osteogenesis imperfecta
- Stress fractures: Repetitive loading — metatarsals (march fracture), tibia, femoral neck (military/athletes)
Pathophysiology
Fractures occur when applied force exceeds bone strength. The pattern depends on the mechanism:
- Direct force: Transverse fracture at point of impact
- Indirect force: Spiral (torsion), oblique (angulation), avulsion (tension)
- Compressive force: Crush/impaction fractures (vertebral bodies, calcaneum)
Fracture healing occurs through inflammation (haematoma), soft callus (fibrocartilage), hard callus (woven bone), and remodelling (lamellar bone). Complete healing takes weeks to months depending on bone and fracture type.
Clinical Presentation
Assessment
- History: Mechanism of injury, time, previous injuries, medications (anticoagulants, steroids), medical history
- Look: Swelling, deformity, bruising, wounds (open fracture), limb shortening/rotation
- Feel: Tenderness (localise to bone), crepitus, temperature, sensation (dermatomes)
- Move: Active and passive ROM; assess joint above and below
- Neurovascular: Pulses, capillary refill, motor and sensory function distal to injury
Fracture Description
- Bone and location (proximal/mid-shaft/distal, intra/extra-articular)
- Pattern (transverse, oblique, spiral, comminuted, segmental, greenstick)
- Displacement (percentage of cortical width) and angulation (degrees, direction of distal fragment)
- Open or closed
Red Flags
- Open fracture — exposed bone or wound communicating with fracture
- Neurovascular compromise — absent pulse, loss of sensation, loss of motor function
- Compartment syndrome — pain out of proportion, pain on passive stretch, tense compartment
- Pathological fracture — minimal trauma in elderly/cancer patient
- Non-accidental injury (children) — inappropriate mechanism, multiple fractures of different ages
Differential Diagnosis
| Injury | Key Features | Investigation |
|---|---|---|
| Fracture | Bony tenderness, deformity, swelling | X-ray (2 views minimum) |
| Dislocation | Joint deformity, fixed abnormal position, loss of ROM | X-ray |
| Ligament sprain | Joint swelling, instability, no bony tenderness | Clinical, MRI |
| Tendon rupture | Loss of function, palpable gap | Clinical, USS/MRI |
| Muscle contusion | Soft tissue swelling, no bony tenderness | Clinical |
| Pathological fracture | Minimal trauma, lytic lesion on X-ray | X-ray, bone profile, CT/MRI |
Diagnosis / Investigation
Bedside
- Neurovascular assessment: Before and after ANY manipulation
- Clinical decision rules: Ottawa Ankle/Knee Rules — reduce unnecessary X-rays
Bloods
- Not routinely needed for isolated fractures
- FBC, G&S, coagulation: For significant fractures requiring surgery
- Bone profile, myeloma screen, PSA: If pathological fracture suspected
Imaging
- X-ray: Minimum 2 views (AP and lateral); include joint above and below
- CT: For complex fractures (intra-articular, spinal, pelvic), surgical planning
- MRI: For occult fractures (scaphoid, femoral neck), ligamentous/soft tissue injury
- Bone scan: For stress fractures, metastases, NAI
Special Tests
- Compartment pressure monitoring: If compartment syndrome suspected (pressure >30 mmHg or within 30 of diastolic pressure)
- DEXA scan: For osteoporotic fragility fractures — guide treatment
Management
Non-pharmacological
- First aid: Splint, ice, elevation
- Reduction: Closed (manipulation under local/regional/general anaesthesia) or open (surgical)
- Immobilisation: POP cast, backslab (allows for swelling), splints, slings
- RICE: Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation — for soft tissue swelling
Pharmacological
- Analgesia: Paracetamol 1g QDS + NSAID (ibuprofen 400mg TDS) + opioid if needed (morphine titrated IV)
- Regional anaesthesia: Femoral nerve block (femoral shaft fracture); Bier's block (forearm fracture reduction); haematoma block (distal radius)
- Open fractures — antibiotics within 1 hour: Co-amoxiclav 1.2g IV (+ gentamicin for Gustilo IIIA/B/C); tetanus prophylaxis
- VTE prophylaxis: For lower limb fractures requiring immobilisation — LMWH per local protocol
- Osteoporosis treatment: If fragility fracture — calcium, vitamin D, bisphosphonate (alendronate 70mg weekly)
Surgical/Interventional
- Closed reduction + cast (MUA): For most displaced fractures with acceptable alignment
- K-wires: Metacarpal, phalangeal fractures; paediatric supracondylar
- Open reduction internal fixation (ORIF): For intra-articular fractures, unstable fractures, failed closed reduction
- Intramedullary nail (IMN): Long bone shaft fractures (femur, tibia)
- External fixation: Open fractures, damage control orthopaedics, periarticular fractures
- Fasciotomy: For compartment syndrome — EMERGENCY within 6 hours
Referral Criteria
- Open fracture — orthopaedic AND plastic surgery (BOAST 4)
- Neurovascular compromise — emergency orthopaedic assessment
- Intra-articular fracture — likely surgical
- All fractures requiring surgery — orthopaedic team
- Fragility fracture — fracture liaison service for osteoporosis assessment
Prognosis
- Most closed fractures: Heal well with appropriate management; healing time 6-12 weeks depending on bone
- Open fractures: Higher infection risk (~2% Gustilo I, ~50% Gustilo IIIC); Gustilo IIIC has ~50% amputation rate
- Compartment syndrome: If fasciotomy delayed >6h, risk of permanent muscle necrosis and Volkmann's contracture
- Non-union risk factors: Smoking, NSAIDs (controversial), inadequate fixation, poor blood supply (scaphoid proximal pole, femoral neck)
- Malunion: Healing in non-anatomical position — may cause functional deficit
Other Relevant Information
Gustilo-Anderson Open Fracture Classification
| Grade | Wound Size | Soft Tissue | Contamination |
|---|---|---|---|
| I | <1cm | Minimal | Minimal |
| II | 1-10cm | Moderate | Moderate |
| IIIA | >10cm | Severe but adequate coverage | Variable |
| IIIB | >10cm | Inadequate coverage (requires flap) | Significant |
| IIIC | Any | Vascular injury requiring repair | Variable |
Ottawa Ankle Rules
| X-ray Required If | Detail |
|---|---|
| Bony tenderness | Posterior edge/tip of lateral malleolus (distal 6cm) |
| Bony tenderness | Posterior edge/tip of medial malleolus (distal 6cm) |
| Bony tenderness | Base of 5th metatarsal |
| Bony tenderness | Navicular bone |
| Inability to weight-bear | Cannot walk 4 steps immediately and in ED |